Turbulence at OpenAI: Legal Reflections on a Surprising Dismissal and Reinstatement
Sam Altman’s dismissal and return to OpenAI raise questions about corporate governance, good faith, talent mobility, and the limits of applying law through algorithms.

In the last weeks of November 2023, the world of artificial intelligence was shaken by an unexpected event: the dismissal and reinstatement of Sam Altman, CEO of OpenAI. This abrupt move, decided by a small group of board members, shocked the technology world. For those unaware, OpenAI, the company behind the ChatGPT, an artificial intelligence system launched in November 2022, took the world by storm within weeks.
Coincidentally, as I was reflecting on legal issues and their application as presented in the notable work 'Dictionary of Hermeneutics' by Lênio Streck (2018), I encountered the case of OpenAI. This event highlights important aspects of law, corporate governance, and business ethics. In a sector driven by disruptive innovations, the OpenAI episode underscores the volatility and significant consequences of decisions made by leaders of influential organizations.
Today, with the advancement of artificial intelligence, a common question arises: will AI replace lawyers and judges? This article, in a very simplistic and thoughtful manner, without any intention of discussing foreign or Brazilian Business Law, or delving into the merits of everything that happened in the OpenAI episode, argues that, despite technological transformations important in various fields of knowledge, the fundamental issues of law, particularly hermeneutics and the application of law, remain unique and should resist 'algorithmization', as they are essentially 'analog'.
Following the developments of the case, an article published in WIRED (Dave, 2023) addressed the issue of OpenAI's 'bizarre' corporate structure, which started as a non-profit organization but formed a for-profit subsidiary in 2019, granting four people the power to dismiss CEO Sam Altman. At this point, we can raise several questions. With this statutory provision allowing the board members to dismiss the CEO, is it an isolated text? Doesn't its understanding depend on the context? Would the dismissal require any substantial justification? Is the mere justification that "He was not consistently honest in his communications with the board." sufficient? Should the interpretation of such a provision observe legal principles and tradition? Can one abuse their right, or should it be exercised within the limits of objective good faith? Does a provision that says the board can dismiss the CEO imply even those without whom the company itself becomes unviable?